The Best Toaster Oven
We analyzed 12,571 reviews from 18 websites to find the best toaster oven. Sources included:
+13 More
Top Toaster Ovens
Why Consider This:
The reasonably priced Panasonic FlashXpress excels at making toast, cookies, and frozen snacks. At around 1 cubic foot in volume, it takes up very little space on a counter, but it’s still large enough to fit four pieces of bread or two slices of leftover pizza.
People Like:
- Fast and convenient
- Great toasting quality
- Great for frozen foods
People Dislike:
- Smaller capacity
- Odd controls
- Short timer
90
Owner Score
3,607 Reviews from 6 Sites
65
Media & Critic Score
2 Media Reviews
Why Consider This:
The Smart Oven® with Element IQ® is a trustworthy tool for the cook who wants a countertop oven that roasts succulent meat, broils, bake pizza, reheas leftovers and toasts evenly. Consider investing in this trusty, solid and clever toaster oven if you plan to use yours for serious cooking. As long as you're not turned off by a $249 price tag.
People Like:
- Easy to use
- Great all-around cooking performance
- Great temperature accuracy
People Dislike:
- Some cooking presets don't work well
- Unobvious smart functions
- Expensive
92
Owner Score
7,421 Reviews from 6 Sites
89
Media & Critic Score
2 Media Reviews
Why Consider This:
Cuisinart®’s Chef’s Convection Toaster Oven boasts 15 cooking functions and offers special settings for speed convection, sandwiches, and bagels. With 1800 watts, the Oven quickly heats up and the Exact Heat™ sensor produces precise temperatures and perfect results every time. The roomy easy-clean nonstick interior can hold a 13-inch pizza, 9 slices of bread, a 9" x 13" baking pan, or an entire chicken for your family dinner!
People Like:
- The instruction manual is well written and easy to follow.
- The two included racks make for efficient operation that optimizes cooking capabilities.
- The oven light is bright, and makes it easy to check on foods without any heat loss.
People Dislike:
- Pricey
- slightly lower performance than other models in price range
- Light bulb is inaccessible
86
Owner Score
1,247 Reviews from 3 Sites
87
Media & Critic Score
2 Media Reviews
How Critic.ly Saves You Time
When it comes to reviewing the best toaster oven, critic.ly is different than other sites. How?
Unbiased & Unsponsored: Critic.ly aggregates and analyzes reviews from real owners and industry critics. We remove spam, sponsored reviews, and other forms of bias to make sure you get the best possible sense of what people actually think about products.
Our reviews of the best toaster ovens were based on 12,571 reviews from 18 websites.
Get the Best Deal: Critic.ly aggregates sales from around the web, so you can get the best deal from a seller you actually trust.
Find the Right Product: Critic.ly lets you search and compare products from thousands of sites in one place.
How to Find the Right Toaster Oven
A toaster oven is a multipurpose appliance that lets you toast bread and bake or reheat food. It’s a nice alternative to firing up your full-size oven, especially in warmer months. It’s also great for small rentals that have tiny kitchens with an oven that doesn’t work well (or is missing altogether),or if you don't think a microwave can satisfy your needs, perhaps a a toaster oven. Also if your kitchen is so active that the oven is full, you can use the toaster oven. Toaster ovens can cost anywhere from $25 to $1,000.
Aside from its performance, a good toaster oven should be intuitive to use with clearly labeled controls and an easy to read display. The most basic features should include adjustable temperature controls (ideally between 150 °F and 450 °F) and adjustable toast-shade settings. Several factors play a role in how evenly food cooks: the distance food is placed from the heating elements, the number of elements used, and the placement of the elements inside the oven.
Toaster Ovens We Eliminated
We research and analyzed 4 toaster ovens. Here's what we concluded about the ones that didn't make the cut.
Runner Up
Highly rated (83 owner score, 0 expert score), but a slight notch below the best.
Sources & Methodology
Critic.ly uses a combination of machine learning and human editors to help you find the best products.
We start by aggregating and analyzing reviews from real owners and industry critics. We remove spam, sponsored reviews, and other forms of bias to make sure you get the best possible sense of what people actually think about products.
We convert every review to a weight average score from 0 to 100.
For this article, we analyzed 12,571 reviews from 18 sites to find the best toaster oven.