The Best Fitness Trackers

We analyzed 60,665 reviews from 38 websites to find the best fitness trackers. Sources included:
WalmartBest BuyDigital TrendsNeweggB&H Photo Video
+33 More

Top Fitness Trackers

Best for Most People
Best Fitness Trackers Fitbit Charge 3 Fitness Tracker
$125 from 12 stores
View All
Why Consider This:
The Fitbit Charge 3 isn't a drastic change over its predecessor, but it has enough small tweaks to make it one of the best everyday fitness trackers you can buy. It's a comfortable wearable that tracks the stats most people want and you don't have to charge it often. Fitbit's app is excellent, and updates to the Charge 3's screen, sensors, and build quality make it an even better buy than its excellent predecessor.
People Like:
  • Large screen
  • Light design
  • Completely waterproof
People Dislike:
  • No onboard GPS
  • Monochrome screen
  • Proprietary charger
84
Owner Score
28,994 Reviews from 9 Sites
85
Media & Critic Score
2 Media Reviews
Buy On Amazon.com
Best Value
Best Fitness Trackers Fitbit Inspire HR Fitness Tracker
$70 from 17 stores
View All
Why Consider This:
This latest tracker is more affordable than the fitness bands it replaces within Fitbit's range and it comes sporting more tech than those older products too. It isn't the most affordable tracker on the market, but everything works well here and it's a great option if you're looking to start tracking your fitness journey.
People Like:
  • Premium design
  • Lots of tracked metrics
  • Strong battery life
People Dislike:
  • No Fitbit Pay
  • Screen can be unresponsive
  • Large bezel
86
Owner Score
14,991 Reviews from 11 Sites
80
Media & Critic Score
2 Media Reviews
Buy On Amazon.com
Top Performance
Best Fitness Trackers Garmin Vívoactive 4S Fitness Tracker
$300 from 16 stores
View All
Why Consider This:
The Garmin Vivoactive 4 puts the tech smarts of the watches used by the ultra-marathon-running elite into a more accessible wearable. You may not get all the pro-style advice of a Forerunner, but you do get the rest.
People Like:
  • Great exercise tracking, with full GPS
  • On-watch music streaming
  • Stacks of stats
People Dislike:
  • Convoluted app installation process
  • ANT+ HR broadcast mode does not work well yet
  • No Performance Condition/training load monitoring
86
Owner Score
977 Reviews from 7 Sites
80
Media & Critic Score
2 Media Reviews
Buy On Amazon.com

How Critic.ly Saves You Time

When it comes to reviewing the best fitness tracker, critic.ly is different than other sites. How?
Unbiased & Unsponsored: Critic.ly aggregates and analyzes reviews from real owners and industry critics. We remove spam, sponsored reviews, and other forms of bias to make sure you get the best possible sense of what people actually think about products.
Our reviews of the best fitness trackers were based on 60,665 reviews from 38 websites.
Get the Best Deal: Critic.ly aggregates sales from around the web, so you can get the best deal from a seller you actually trust.
Find the Right Product: Critic.ly lets you search and compare products from thousands of sites in one place.

How to Find the Right Fitness Tracker

Fitness trackers can give you a better idea of how and how much you move your body throughout the day and night. They’re for people who want to set goals to increase daily movement, exercise more often, and improve sleep habits. These trackers (and their apps) are also for people who want a place to log their diets, hydration, and even menstrual cycles to gain a broader picture of their health. The differences among these trackers are principally in the number of sensors—and therefore features—they offer and, most important, how easy they are to use. The lines that separate GPS running watches and smartwatches from dedicated fitness trackers are blurrier than ever. GPS watches can now track your activities all day and your sleep at night. Smartwatches can now capture your movement with automatic activity detection and built-in GPS. Some people may still prefer a dedicated fitness tracker for several reasons, though. For starters, fitness trackers are much less bulky to wear than GPS running watches, and they usually cost a lot less. Unlike smartwatches, they can run for up to a week between charges (whereas you generally need to charge a smartwatch daily). And the latest generation of trackers goes well beyond just counting steps and recording workouts: They include more smartwatch features than before—from interactive notifications to third-party apps—and additional sensors to provide more granular detail on movement and sleep.

Fitness Trackers We Eliminated

We research and analyzed 7 fitness trackers. Here's what we concluded about the ones that didn't make the cut.
Fitbit Flex 2 Fitness Tracker
Runner Up
Highly rated (81 owner score, 75 expert score), but a slight notch below the best.
Samsung Galaxy Fit Fitness Tracker
Runner Up
Highly rated (82 owner score, 70 expert score), but a slight notch below the best.
Samsung Gear Fit2 Pro Fitness Tracker
Runner Up
Highly rated (82 owner score, 70 expert score), but a slight notch below the best.
Garmin Vivosmart 4 Fitness Tracker
Runner Up
Highly rated (79 owner score, 65 expert score), but a slight notch below the best.

Sources & Methodology

Critic.ly uses a combination of machine learning and human editors to help you find the best products.
We start by aggregating and analyzing reviews from real owners and industry critics. We remove spam, sponsored reviews, and other forms of bias to make sure you get the best possible sense of what people actually think about products.
We convert every review to a weight average score from 0 to 100.
For this article, we analyzed 60,665 reviews from 38 sites to find the best fitness tracker.